ב”ה

This class is a chassidic discourse by the Alter Rebbe, Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, of blessed memory, from his book Torah Or. In this class the Alter Rebbe discusses the difference we find in the creation of Man’s body and soul compared to the rest of the creatures: all creatures where created body and soul at once, while man’s body was created separated from his soul and the united.

Why Was Man’s Body Created From Dust?

A discourse of the Alter Rebbe, Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi (Torah Or)

In this class we learn a discourse by the Alter Rebbe, Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi, of blessed memory, from his book Torah Or. The discourse looks at a difference in the creation of man. All other creatures were created with body and soul together. Man’s body was created first, separate from his soul, and only afterwards were the two united.

The message in one sentence

Let’s start from the end. The message of the discourse is a call to action: You, human being, are responsible for the whole world. Man is the only creature that can bring the whole creation to the purpose for which G-d created it. The Talmud says the same thing, which is why man was created alone.1

The discourse starts simply and becomes deeper and more mystical at the end. There is no need to be afraid of that. The only goal is to understand that we are responsible for the world.

The question

There are four kinds of creatures. In Hebrew they are domem (inanimate, like stones), tzomeach (plants, which grow), chai (animals, which also move) and medaber (human beings, who speak and can choose to serve G-d).

The Torah describes the creation of the body of man differently from the others:

This looks like a low beginning. Man’s body started at the level of the inanimate, even lower than the body of an animal. Yet man is the highest creation. David says to G-d, “Behind and before You have formed me.”8 “Behind” means he was created last. It can also mean the lowest of the low.

So why was man created this way?

Answer, part one: why body and soul could not come together

The four kinds of creatures match the four letters of G-d’s Name (the Name of four letters, Havayah). G-d has infinite Names, because He is infinite and every Name is an expression of Him. But this Name, which G-d Himself made known to us, expresses Him as the Creator beyond time and space. One meaning of it is “He was, He is, and He will be.”

The letters match the four levels like this:

A human being has all four levels inside himself. We grow like plants. We move like animals. We have a stone-like body, a plant-like aspect, an animal-like aspect, and the “human within the human,” the speaking soul. The Torah even says that “man is a tree of the field.”9 Onkelos, a convert who wrote an Aramaic translation and explanation of the Torah, translates “a living soul” as “a speaking spirit.”10 Speech is what sets us apart.

Now the key point. An animal is made of a body and a soul. The body is of the plant level, because it is born small and grows. The soul is the animal soul. Plant and animal are two neighboring levels, with nothing between them. That is why they could be created together, in one act.

Man is different. His body has a plant-like aspect, just as an animal’s body has a plant-like aspect. But his soul is on the highest level, and there is a whole level between it and the plant: the animal. In terms of the letters, the Yud and the Vav are separated by a Hei. The distance between man’s soul and even a plant-like body is infinite. So a human body and soul could not have come out of the earth together.

(Even infinity has levels. A line has infinitely many points. A plane has infinitely many lines. So the infinity of a plane is greater than the infinity of a line, which is greater than the infinity of points. We can say man is far from the plant by “two infinities,” with the animal in the middle.)

A remark by Rabbi Serber

The Alter Rebbe does not say this, but it follows from his words, so the rabbi mentions it. Judaism does not teach that man is just a more developed animal. Evolution and the Big Bang are theories. An honest scientist will say that they cannot be proven for certain. One may just as well assume that G-d created the world. The difference is what follows from it. If I believe I am only a better monkey, there is no purpose, and I may behave like a monkey. If I believe G-d created me with a purpose, I have a responsibility. G-d gave a human soul to every single human being, with no exceptions. Because of that we have a responsibility.

Answer, part two: why the body was specifically of dust

Why was the body made of the lowest level, and not of the plant level? Because man is the purpose of the whole creation.

(This does not mean we may do what we want with the world, for example cut down all the trees in the Amazon. It means we are responsible for the world.)

G-d created everything with words, such as “Let there be light.” Words carry energy. The letters “yud he wav he” in the right order carry a message. The words of G-d carry creative energy, and they are continuously being spoken so that creation can exist. (The Tanya starts its second part with this idea.11)

When this divine energy comes down into a stone, a plant or an animal, it becomes hidden. You only see a stone. A stone or a dog cannot serve G-d. But man can. When he uses the world in the right way to serve G-d, he elevates the divine sparks hidden in it. We eat food and then learn Torah with the strength of that food. We wear clothes and then do a mitzvah in them. In this way the food and the clothes are elevated too. (Of course, man can also misuse the world, for example by building a nuclear bomb.)

The Alter Rebbe gives an example: a lever. To raise a house, you must put the lever under the lowest beam. Then the whole wall rises. If you push from the middle of the wall, the bottom does not rise. In the same way, the soul of man, the highest of the high, was placed in a body of the lowest of the low. When man elevates himself, he elevates everything: first the inanimate, then the plants above it, and so on.

That is why man is called medaber. It comes from the expression yadber amim tachteinu in Psalms, usually translated “He subdues peoples under us.”12 The word yadber can also mean “to lead.” Read personally, the “peoples under me” are my body, my food and everything I touch. My task is to lead them toward G-d. A human being is the leader of the creation.

Man’s soul also could not be placed in a plant-level body. Then he could not have elevated what is below him.

The deeper level: “the beginning is wedged in the end”

The Alter Rebbe now brings a verse: “With wisdom G-d founded the earth, and He established the heavens with understanding.”13

Here “heavens” and “earth” mean the spiritual and the physical. “Earth” is the inanimate, the lowest. “Heavens” is the plant level. Plants are already somewhat spiritual, because they grow. In human terms, our words are like stones, because once said they do not change. Our emotions are like plants, because they grow from small to great.

The verse seems strange. Wisdom (Chochmah) is higher than understanding (Binah). We would expect the higher wisdom to go with the higher heavens. But the verse does the opposite: wisdom with the earth, and understanding with the heavens.

The explanation is a principle from the Sefer Yetzirah, the Book of Formation: “Their beginning is wedged in their end, and their end in their beginning.”14

An example: you want a house, so you call an architect. During construction you visit the site and see dirt, sand and rubble. “This is disgusting, I don’t want it!” But the architect says, “I’m not finished.” When you receive the key and see the finished house, you say, “This is what I wanted.” The first thing you thought about is the end result. All the work in between was only a way to get there. So the beginning and the end are connected. Man, the last creation, was the first thought of creation. That is why he is responsible for everything.

Now to wisdom and understanding. Chochmah is like a seed. A whole apple tree with all its apples is already inside it, but you cannot see it, and the seed does not even taste like an apple. Binah is the development of that seed. Think of the picture of the house in your mind. You tell the architect, “I see my house.” He answers, “I can’t see it. Explain it to me, point by point.” That explanation is Binah.

Our emotions are born from Binah. The more I understand something, the stronger my attraction or rejection becomes. If someone offers you a drink and you don’t know it is poison, you might drink it. If he explains that you will die in five minutes, you say, “Take it away.” That is how understanding creates emotion. Chochmah is beyond this. Because it is the beginning, it is wedged in the end, and so the verse connects it with the earth, the lowest level.

This is why man’s body was first like earth, a golem, and then the soul came into it. His soul comes from the highest source, Chochmah, and “with wisdom He founded the earth.”

The two Names

One last point. For the other creatures, the Torah uses one Name of G-d, Elokim, which stands for nature. For man it says Havayah Elokim, two Names. Man’s soul and body are infinitely far apart, so more is needed to join them. Havayah is an expression of G-d beyond limits, and Elokim is a limited expression of G-d. They are used together so the highest of the high can be joined with the lowest of the low.

Conclusion

The creation of man was not a low beginning. It gave man his task. The highest soul was placed in the lowest body so that man can reach down and lift up the entire creation, and so that he can choose to serve G-d and bring everything around him back to Him.

Sources

  1. Sefer Yetzirah 1:7. ↩

    Sanhedrin 37a-38a (man created alone). ↩
  2. Genesis 1:11. ↩
  3. Genesis 1:20. ↩
  4. Rosh Hashanah 11a; Chullin 60a. ↩
  5. Genesis 2:7. ↩
  6. Sanhedrin 38b. ↩
  7. Psalms 139:16. ↩
  8. Psalms 139:5. ↩
  9. Deuteronomy 20:19. ↩
  10. Onkelos on Genesis 2:7. ↩
  11. Tanya, Part II (Shaar HaYichud VeHaEmunah), beginning, quoting Psalms 119:89. ↩
  12. Psalms 47:4. ↩
  13. Proverbs 3:19. ↩

By Rabbi Tuvia Serber

© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further.

Our blogs may contain text/quotes/references/links that include copyright material of Mechon-Mamre.org, Aish.com, Sefaria.org, Chabad.org, and/or AskNoah.org, which we use in accordance with their policies.