בס”ד
This article is a summary of the lesson. It is highly recommended to watch the full lesson on YouTube for a more detailed explanation, additional examples and the discussions that took place during the class.
What Is Ona’at Devarim?
In previous lessons, we explored lashon hara and rechilut: speaking negatively about someone to a third person. This lesson focuses on a different concept: ona’at devarim, which means hurting or wronging someone directly through words.
The Torah discusses two forms of ona’ah in Vayikra (Leviticus), Chapter 25. The first, in verse 14, concerns taking advantage of someone in a business transaction. The second, in verse 17, concerns causing someone distress through words.
The sages explain that ona’at devarim includes much more than obvious insults or cruel remarks. It also covers subtle comments that can cause embarrassment, sadness or emotional pain.
G-d Knows Our Intentions
There is an interesting difference between the two Torah verses. The verse concerning business transactions does not mention fearing G-d, whereas the verse concerning harmful speech does.
The sages explain that this is because words are often open to interpretation. When confronted, someone can easily say, “I was only joking” or “I didn’t mean it that way.”
But G-d knows what is truly going on inside our minds. We may be able to convince other people that our intentions were innocent, but we cannot hide our real intentions from G-d.
This reminds us to be conscious not only of what we say, but also of why we say it.
The Hidden Harm of Everyday Comments
Ona’at devarim is not limited to obvious insults. Some of the most damaging examples are surprisingly subtle.
Consider a young woman whose boyfriend once commented that her ears stuck out. She had never really noticed this before, but his remark stayed with her for years. She became self-conscious and tried various ways to hide her ears.
One seemingly casual comment had a lasting impact on how she saw herself.
The same principle applies when we remind someone of mistakes they made in the past, particularly when they have already repented and changed their behaviour. Bringing up someone’s previous wrongdoing can make them feel embarrassed and diminish their efforts to move forward.
Even telling someone who has converted to Judaism that they were not always Jewish can cause discomfort. Unless we know that the person is completely comfortable discussing their background, we should avoid bringing it up.
Another example given by the sages concerns someone who proudly shows you a new handbag or dress. You discover that they paid $100 more than they could have elsewhere.
Should you tell them?
If they can still easily do something about it, perhaps your information will help. But if the purchase is already final and returning it would involve considerable effort, your comment may simply destroy their happiness.
You may think you are being helpful, but all you have achieved is making someone feel bad.
Pranks: When Does Humour Become Cruelty?
Practical jokes and pranks can also fall under ona’at devarim.
The sages give an example of someone who asks where to buy food for their donkeys and is deliberately sent to the wrong shop. Today, we would probably call this a prank.
But when does a prank stop being funny and become cruel?
A useful distinction is whether the person being pranked experiences genuine fear, distress or concern for their safety or property.
Even if everyone laughs afterwards, we must consider what the victim experienced during the prank.
For example, deliberately making someone believe that their car has been destroyed may cause several minutes of genuine panic and emotional distress. The fact that the car is eventually revealed to be unharmed does not erase those feelings.
The same applies to jokes at someone else’s expense. If the humour depends on making another person frightened, angry or embarrassed, we should seriously question whether it is acceptable.
Someone else’s suffering should never be the price of our entertainment.
Think Before You Press Send
The prohibition of ona’at devarim applies to written communication as much as spoken words. Emails, social media comments and online videos can all cause considerable harm.
Many people behave differently behind a screen. They write things online that they would never say to someone’s face.
One practical solution is to develop the habit of never immediately sending or posting a comment. Wait ten minutes, read it again and ask yourself:
- Would I say this directly to the person’s face?
- Is this comment actually necessary?
- Am I trying to help, or am I simply expressing my frustration?
- Could I address this issue privately rather than publicly?
This simple pause can prevent a great deal of unnecessary hurt.
The Importance of Sensitivity When Someone Is Grieving
One of the most important applications of ona’at devarim is how we behave towards people who are grieving.
In Jewish tradition, the seven-day mourning period is called shiva. During this time, friends, relatives and members of the community visit the mourners to offer comfort.
Interestingly, Jewish tradition teaches that visitors should not feel obliged to fill the silence with conversation. Their primary role is to be present and give the mourners the opportunity to speak about the person they have lost.
Sometimes, however, people say things that are deeply insensitive.
Imagine telling someone who has just lost their mother:
“You don’t know how lucky you are. My mother died when I was three, so you had twenty more years with yours.”
Although the intention may be to encourage gratitude, this is not the moment to compare experiences or minimise someone’s grief.
A mourner does not need to hear that they should feel fortunate. They need to know that their pain is acknowledged.
A particularly moving example illustrates this beautifully. Following a terrorist attack in the Jerusalem neighbourhood of Har Nof, a family was sitting shiva for a relative who had been murdered.
One visitor explained that he had travelled all the way from Boston simply because he wanted to be there for the family. He had never even known the deceased.
Another young visitor explained that he had lost both his parents in an earlier terrorist attack and his best friend in another. He, too, had come simply to be with the grieving family.
Neither visitor tried to compare suffering or suggest that someone else’s pain was less significant than their own. They simply offered their presence and understanding.
That is what genuine comfort looks like.
Acknowledge Feelings Instead of Dismissing Them
The lesson extends far beyond bereavement.
When someone shares their difficulties or expresses emotional pain, our immediate reaction is sometimes to say:
- “You shouldn’t feel that way.”
- “It’s not that bad.”
- “Look at the positive side.”
- “Why are you so upset?”
We often say these things because we genuinely want to help. We want the other person to feel better.
But by immediately dismissing their emotions, we risk making them feel even more isolated.
Instead, we should begin by acknowledging their feelings:
“I understand that you feel this way.”
“I can see how difficult this is for you.”
“I’m here if you want to talk.”
Only after someone feels heard and understood should we try to help them look at the situation differently or find ways to ease their burden.
The Takeaway
Ona’at devarim teaches us that words have enormous power. We can hurt someone through an obvious insult, but we can also cause pain through a seemingly innocent remark, an ill-timed joke, an unnecessary criticism or an attempt to minimise someone’s suffering.
Before speaking, we should ask ourselves not only whether something is true, but also whether it needs to be said and how it might affect the person hearing it.
We cannot always remove another person’s pain, but we can make sure that we do not add to it.
Sometimes the greatest kindness is not finding the right words, but knowing when to listen, when to remain silent and simply be there for someone.
Talk from Rabbi Menachem Salasnik
The above is a representation of the spoken text converted to written text.
© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further.
Our blogs may contain text/quotes/references/links that include copyright material of Mechon-Mamre.org, Aish.com, Sefaria.org, Chabad.org, and/or AskNoah.org, which we use in accordance with their policies.