בס”ד

This blog is a summary of a class. We recommend watching the whole class.


There is more than one opinion among the great rabbis on this question. In this class I share what I saw written and what I think myself. That is not the only opinion, and it is not the only way to go.

What does “mitzvah” really mean?

Mitzvah is usually translated as “commandment”. G-d says do this, or don’t do that. Chassidic teaching adds a deeper meaning. A mitzvah does not bring something new into the Torah. It brings new life and new light into what is already there.

The Previous Rebbe gave this example.¹ A very simple person feels like a nobody in front of a great sage. The sage does not even see him as someone he can have a relationship with. This is not an insult. There is just no connection.

Then the sage asks the simple man to do something for him. Now both of them change. The simple man feels that he exists, because the sage needs him. The sage also sees him as someone he can speak to. The command connects the two. It does not matter if the task is big or small.

This is why the word mitzvah is linked to the Aramaic tzavta, which means connection. A mitzvah creates a bond between G-d and man. The Alter Rebbe said that if G-d had commanded us to chop wood, we would chop wood with joy.

So it does not matter if a custom looks nice. Family, a table, food and candles are lovely, but you can have them without being Jewish. Jews keep mitzvot because G-d wants it. So “it is so beautiful” is not a good reason for a non-Jew to take on a Jewish custom.

The mitzvot are the limbs of the King

The Zohar says that the mitzvot are the “limbs of the King”.² This does not mean G-d has a body. It is an example to help us understand.

Every person has a soul and a body. Each part of the body is a vessel for a power of the soul. The eyes brings forth  the power to see, the ears the power to hear, and the mouth the power to speak. A blind person can have children who see well. So the soul was not missing the power to see. The vessel did not work.

In the same way, each mitzvah draws down and brings forth a specific G-dly energy. When a Jew keeps a mitzvah, he draws down that energy.

What about a non-Jew? The sources say that a non-Jew who keeps a mitzvah that was not given to him does not draw down that energy. A mitzvah is a connection that G-d starts from above. He told the Jewish people: when you do this, I will give you that. We cannot force G-d to answer when we start a connection from below. G-d connected Himself to the Jewish people in this way, and not to the nations.

What does the Rambam say?

The Rambam writes that a non-Jew who wants to keep a mitzvah of the Jews in order to receive reward, we don’t prevent him from doing it.³ He must do it in the right way, as the Torah and the Oral Torah describe. The Rambam gives examples: charity, and an animal offering.

The Radbaz (Rabbi David ibn Zimra, Egypt, 1500s, a teacher of the Arizal) adds a point.⁴ If a non-Jew says, “I was commanded to do this,” then he may not do it. But if he says, “I know I was not commanded, but I want a reward,” he may. Still, the Radbaz says that for things that need holiness and ritual purity, like writing tefillin, a mezuzah or a Torah scroll, he is inclined to be strict. He says his heart dislikes the idea.

The Rambam also gives two exceptions: a non-Jew may not study Torah in the way that is forbidden, and he may not keep Shabbat.⁵ And also gives  a general rule: a non-Jew may not make a new religion. The Rambam does not explain this. In my opinion it means that a person may not invent mitzvot and say “G-d told me to do this”. Going to the gym is fine. Saying that G-d commanded you to go to the gym is not.

Is there a reward?

The Divine Code  based on Rabbi Moshe Feinstein (Igros Moshe) says that a non-Jew who keeps a Jewish mitzvah gets no spiritual reward. It makes no sense, he say, because there is no connection. Moshe Feinstein does not fully trust the writings of the Radbaz on this point, because those were found later.⁶

Other authorities, and the Rebbe in many places, say there is a spiritual reward. I cannot explain exactly what that reward is. I also cannot explain exactly what the reward is for a Jew. On this question I follow these other opinions, and I disagree with the Divine Code.

There are two kinds of reward. The first is for a person who was commanded and does it. The second is for a person who was not commanded and does it anyway. It sounds like the second is higher. But the first is higher, because it comes from G-d down to us. Think of a simple man who brings the sage a cup of water that the sage did not ask for. The sage does not have to be happy about it. So the non-Jew does get a reward, but not the same reward as a Jew who was commanded.

The Rabbinic commandments

The Torah says we may not add to the mitzvot or take away from them.⁷ But our sages set up seven Rabbinic commandments:

  1. Lighting Shabbat candles
  2. Blessings
  3. Washing hands
  4. Hallel
  5. Chanukah
  6. Purim
  7. Eruv (carrying on Shabbat in a public area)

This does not add new mitzvot to the Torah. The Torah itself tells us to follow what the sages say,⁸ so by doing this we keep a Torah mitzvah. That is why the blessing says “who has commanded us”. G-d commanded us to follow our sages.

Most authorities, and the Rambam, agree that non-Jews are not obligated in the Rabbinic commandments. So a non-Jew should not say the blessing over Chanukah candles. By saying it he would be saying “I am commanded”. And even the Radbaz, who says there is a reward, says: do not think you are obligated.

What about blessings?

I do not agree with people who make up new blessings for non-Jews. That makes a new religion. Even after the Talmud was closed, the sages did not add blessings. The Geonim added one blessing around the year 1000, and there is still an argument about whether to say it.

But I think the usual blessings for food can be taught to non-Jews. Nobody says a non-Jew is obligated. But the Talmud says we should not enjoy the world without thanking G-d, and many non-Jews already say thanks before and after eating. So it makes some sense.

Honoring parents and giving charity are different. These make sense to every human being.⁹ A non-Jew should do them anyway.

Signs of the covenant

Shabbat, the Jewish holidays, tefillin,  mezuzah and others are signs of the covenant between G-d and the Jewish people. When a non-Jew keeps them, what does it show? It shows a connection that is not his. Even the opinions that say there is a spiritual reward agree on this.

Circumcision is a special case. It is also a sign of the covenant, and we do it because the Torah commands it, not because Abraham did it.¹⁰ But the Divine Code says many others anyway do it, and a non-Jew can do it as an offering to G-d. A Jewish mohel may decide for himself whether he wants to be involved.

The story of the mezuzah

The Talmud tells of King Artaban of Persia.¹¹ He sent a precious stone to Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi and expected a gift in return. Rabbi Yehuda sent a mezuzah. The king was angry: “I sent a jewel and you sent me a worthless piece of parchment!” The messenger answered: your jewel must be guarded, but this gift will guard you. According to the story, the king later put the mezuzah on the door of his sick daughter, and she was healed.

This does not mean every non-Jew should put up a mezuzah. I am not Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi. The Rebbe also said that we should not rely so much on segulot (special cures), because every person and every situation is different.

Do it the right way, and ask a rabbi

If you do something, do it the right way. Once a couple without children asked the Rebbe for a blessing. He asked if they kept the laws of family purity. They answered, “so-so.” The Rebbe answered with a question: do you want a son “so-so”? A cup with a hole cannot hold water. If you do not know how to do something, do not do it. Ask a rabbi.

Ask yourself why you want to do it. Do you want to look like a Jew? Then there is a path: convert, with a rabbi who guides you. If you cannot or do not want to convert, then maybe G-d does not want you to take on this practice.

Choose a rabbi who knows you. Be ready to answer: why do you want this, and where are you in your life? And if he says no, do not go looking for another rabbi until you hear yes. You are not fooling G-d, and you are not fooling the rabbi. You are only fooling yourself.

Conclusion

In my humble opinion, others will say differently. Can a non-Jew keep the mitzvot of the Jews? Yes. Most of them? Yes. All of them? No. The holy ones, no. The less holy ones, yes. Which ones? Talk to a rabbi, and be ready to answer his questions honestly first to yourself.

Shiur from Rabbi Tuvia Serber

Footnotes

  1. The Previous Rebbe, Rabbi Yosef Yitzchak Schneersohn, from the text shown on the slide.
  2. Zohar; see also the sources in the class slides.
  3. Rambam, Laws of Kings 10:10.
  4. Radbaz on the Rambam, Laws of Kings 10:10.
  5. Rambam, Laws of Kings 10:9. The two laws are in this order in the Rambam; in the class I changed the order for clarity.
  6. Igros Moshe (Rabbi Moshe Feinstein), in several places. The Radbaz’s and the Meiri’s writings on this point were found later.
  7. Deuteronomy 4:2.
  8. Deuteronomy 17:11.
  9. For example, Sefer HaChinuch.
  10. Leviticus 12:3.
  11. Talmud, Avodah Zarah 11a.



© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further.

Our blogs may contain text/quotes/references/links that include copyright material of 
Mechon-Mamre.org, Aish.com, Sefaria.org, Chabad.org, and/or AskNoah.org, which we use in accordance with their policies.