בס"ד

If This Path Is Real, What Is My Responsibility?

This is the third part of a three-part reflection.

In the first talk, we asked a painful but honest question:
If I don’t become Jewish, is there truly a place for me in this Torah and in this Torah community?

In the second, we moved from identity to practice:
What does it actually look like to live as a Noahide, with prayer, study, and community, without imitation?

Tonight, the question becomes simpler and more concrete:

If this path is real, what is my job?
What does responsibility actually look like, not in theory, not as private spirituality, but in real life, among real people, over time?

Because faith that remains private eventually weakens.
And faith that never takes responsibility never matures.

The Noahide Covenant Is Not New

The Seven Laws of Noah are not a modern invention. They appear at the very beginning of the Torah itself.

Humanity is first addressed as morally accountable before G-d with Adam in Genesis chapters 1–2. After the Flood, that responsibility is clarified and renewed when G-d speaks to Noah and his descendants—not as tribes, nations, or religions, but as humanity as such (Genesis 9:1–7).

The Talmud in Sanhedrin codifies these obligations as seven foundational categories. These laws precede Sinai. They belong to humanity.

Later, during the biblical period and especially in the Second Temple era, we encounter a group known as Yirei Hashem of Yirei Shamayim—“G-d-fearers.” This category is already implied in Tanakh (see Psalms 115:11) and described explicitly in Second Temple sources.

Who were they?

They were non-Jews who rejected idolatry, accepted the G-d of Israel, practiced justice and charity, prayed, and attached themselves to Jewish communal life without converting.

Josephus describes them as participants in Jewish communal spaces. Other Second Temple and early Roman-era sources attest to non-Jews praying, learning, and attending synagogues while remaining non-Jews.

Even the Book of Acts—despite its later theological trajectory, preserves historical traces of this phenomenon. The existence of “G-d-fearers” clearly predates Christianity and stands independent of it.

They were known as the righteous among the nations.

Why This Path Disappeared—and Why It Is Reemerging

History then took a sharp turn.

Missionary religions arose, demanding uniform belief and identity. Empires enforced theology through coercion. Moral responsibility was replaced with conversion or compliance.

The Noahide framework did not disappear, but it went dormant.

Only in the modern era, through global communication, freedom of conscience, and the collapse of enforced belief, has it become possible again for a universal moral covenant to exist without coercion.

And something else has happened in our time:

The Jewish people have returned to their land.

Today, more than half of the world’s Jewish population lives in Israel. The prophets never described this as an isolated event, but as part of a larger unfolding, one in which the nations turn toward Jerusalem not to become Israel, but to serve G-d.

This theme appears already in the Exodus. Pharaoh is told that the plagues are not merely punishment but revelation:

“For this reason I have kept you alive, to show you My power, and so that My name will be proclaimed throughout the earth.”
(Exodus 9:16)

Even Pharaoh, the antagonist, is addressed as a moral subject meant to recognize G-d.

Zechariah later describes a future where the nations ascend to Jerusalem on Sukkot, not to convert, but to recognize G-d’s kingship (Zechariah 14:9, 16–19).

This vision assumes something crucial:
Israel restored in its land, and the nations standing alongside, each in their role.

The absence of a mature Noahide civilization is not a failure.
It is a sign that we are early.

Community Comes Before Institutions

One of the most common frustrations Noahides express is:
“Where is our community?”

It’s an honest and necessary question.

But the Torah always builds in a specific order:
people → responsibility → structure

Judaism did not begin with synagogues, prayer books, or schools. The Mishnah teaches that civilization rests on Torah, divine service, and acts of kindness (Pirkei Avot 1:2)—lived realities before institutions.

Historically, G-d-fearers attached themselves to Jewish communal spaces, especially synagogues, not as converts, but as learners and moral participants.

Every civilization begins organically: families, elders, shared responsibility, living teachers.

So must this one.

Today, many Noahide spaces exist, organizations, online study groups, discussion forums, social media communities, lectures, and recorded classes. These play an important role, especially early on.

But we must be honest about their limits.

Not every space offers depth.
Not every teacher offers reliable guidance.
Watching videos, even excellent ones, cannot replace accountability, real relationships, and shared responsibility.

Torah is not meant to be consumed passively.
It is lived, questioned, corrected, and transmitted in community.

Institutions do not create community.
Community creates institutions.

Leadership Without Clergy

A Noahide civilization will not mirror Jewish life.

Halakhically, the Noahide covenant is distinct from Sinai. There is no Noahide priesthood, no parallel clergy, and no replacement for rabbinic authority (see Sanhedrin; Rambam, Hilchot Melachim 8–10).

But this does niet mean leadership without guidance.

The Torah insists that moral clarity requires qualified authority (Deuteronomy 17:8–11), and Rambam applies this principle to Noahides as well.

That means ongoing relationship with qualified rabbis and Jewish teachers—men and women—who can teach, guide, and safeguard Torah clarity. Not as rulers, not as missionaries, and not as gatekeepers to conversion, but as anchors.

Within that framework, leadership is still required:

Most concretely, Noahides must take responsibility for building learning environments:
local groups, guided programs, curated curricula, conferences, and gatherings.

These are not luxuries. They are how civilizations grow.

And like every enduring culture, this work must begin with children.

A civilization that does not teach its children does not survive.

Israel’s Role—and Ours

Israel’s role is not to rule the nations, but to teach.

For 2,000 years, Jews lived as vulnerable minorities, exiled, persecuted, often forbidden from teaching Torah to outsiders on pain of death. Silence was survival, not rejection.

If Noahides want access to Jewish wisdom, they must create the conditions for it, invite teachers, build frameworks, and take responsibility.

Judaism does not spread through conquest or recruitment.
It illuminates what is already true:

“The earth is Hashem’s, and all that fills it.” (Psalms 24:1)

Different peoples can serve the same G-d through different covenants.

A Noahide civilization grows alongside Israel, not over it, not instead of it.

Responsibility, Not Waiting

This path will require experimentation, but guided experimentation. Sincerity alone does not guarantee truth or safety.

The task is not to invent something new.
It is to discover what already exists and live it collectively.

So what are the first steps?

They are simple and human:

People meet.
They recognize they are not alone.
They speak, listen, learn, and take responsibility together, under guidance, not in isolation.

Then comes the harder step:

Step forward.

Do not wait for permission that will never come.
Do not wait for institutions that cannot exist without people.

Ask honestly:

The world is not waiting to be debated.
It is waiting to be perfected.

But this must be done with humility, without power struggles, without imitation, without ego.

Not another religion.
Not a replacement.
But civilization itself.

Humanity was created from one person so no one could claim moral superiority over another (Sanhedrin 4).

Every generation receives a difficult task.

Ours may be this:
to prove that humanity can stand before God without coercion, without erasure, unified in responsibility.

This is not a future fantasy.

It is work.

And it has already begun.

Door rabbijn Tani Burton

Meer shiurim van Rabbi Tani Burton

 © Copyright, alle rechten voorbehouden. Als je dit artikel leuk vond, moedigen we je aan om het verder te verspreiden.

Onze blogs kunnen tekst/quotes/verwijzingen/links bevatten die auteursrechtelijk beschermd materiaal bevatten van Mechon-Mamre.org, Aish.nl, Sefaria.org, Chabad.orgen/of VraagNoah.orgdie we gebruiken in overeenstemming met hun beleid.