בס”ד

Parashat Vayetze
On this week’s Torah reading we find Yaakov marring two sisters: Leah and Rachel. However, our sages say that the forefathers kept the whole Torah, 613 Mitzvot, even before it was given, and it is forbidden to marry two sisters: why did Yaakov do it?
Based on Likutei Sichot, vol. 5, p. 141


Can You Marry Two Sisters?

For a Jew, the law is clear: you may not marry two sisters. For a non-Jew, the law is that you may. In this week’s Torah reading we find the story of Jacob, who married two sisters, Leah and Rachel.

The story in short

Jacob met Rachel, the youngest daughter of Laban, who would become his father-in-law. He promised her: “I will marry you.” Then he went to Laban’s house and worked for seven years. But Laban tricked him and gave him Leah instead of Rachel. So Jacob married Leah.

When Jacob found out, he asked Laban: “Why did you deceive me?” Laban answered that the youngest daughter may not marry before the oldest daughter. “You married Leah. That is what you have.” Jacob said that he still wanted to marry Rachel. Laban agreed. A week later Jacob also married Rachel, and then he worked another seven years. In total, he worked fourteen years.

The question

Our sages tell us that the forefathers, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and their children kept all 613 commandments of the Torah. They did this even before the Torah was given, when they were not yet obligated.

So here is the question: if Jacob kept the whole Torah, how could he marry two sisters? It is not allowed. We cannot say that Jacob did not keep the whole Torah, because we just said that he did.

This is a famous question with a few answers. I will share a few of them, and then I will share the answer of the Rebbe, which fits much more easily with the simple meaning of the text.

First answer: outside the Land of Israel

The first answer says that the forefathers kept the whole Torah only in the Land of Israel. Jacob was in Haran, which is somewhere around Syria today. So he married two sisters outside of the Land of Israel.

This is interesting, but there is a problem. Rashi explains the simple meaning of the text. He says that Jacob sent a message to Esau: “I lived in the house of Laban and I kept the 613 commandments.” So according to Rashi, Jacob kept all 613 commandments in Haran too. This means that Rashi does not agree with the answer of the Ramban.

Second answer: G-d said so

Another answer is that Jacob married Leah first and then Rachel because G-d told him to. But we do not find anywhere that G-d told Jacob to marry Rachel. He married Leah, the oldest, and then suddenly G-d said, “Go and marry Rachel”? Nothing like this is written.

Third answer: they converted

Another answer is that Jacob, Leah and Rachel converted to Judaism, whatever Judaism was at that time. The law is that someone who converts is like a newborn child. So legally speaking, Leah and Rachel were no longer sisters. That is why Jacob could marry two women, and not two sisters.

But let us think about why you may not marry two sisters. The relationship between two wives of one man is called tzarah in Hebrew. This word means suffering. They are jealous of each other: “You married my husband. He loves me more than you.” There is a whole bunch of problems. This is why men who had more than one wife kept them in different houses.

Two sisters are different. Sisters usually love each other. So if Jacob marries two sisters, he creates a conflict between them: “We love each other, but you married my husband.”

Now, even if Leah and Rachel converted and were legally not sisters, they were still sisters in real life. They would still be hurt by this, because he is “my husband.” So this answer also does not fit the simple meaning of the text.

The answer of the Rebbe

Now we come to the answer of the Rebbe. At the end of the day, very superficially speaking, Jacob was a non-Jew, and so was Leah. Judaism starts with the giving of the Torah, after the Exodus from Egypt. So none of them were obligated to keep the commandments.

But the family of the forefathers accepted upon themselves to be strict and to keep all 613 commandments.

Now we come to this specific situation. Jacob promised Rachel that he would marry her. This is written in the text.

Here a conflict comes up. Non-Jews are obligated not to deceive others. If they are not obligated, then at least they accepted it upon themselves. We see this in the text. When Jacob speaks to Laban, he asks: “Why did you deceive me?” If deceiving was allowed, what is the question? Of course Laban was allowed to deceive him. But Jacob had a good question, because people do not do this. Laban gave all kinds of answers, but that is not important now.

So there is a conflict. On one side, Jacob must not deceive. Non-Jews are obligated in all the rational commandments, so he was obligated not to deceive, or at least he accepted it upon himself. On the other side, he took on a stringency, to keep the 613 commandments, which he was not obligated to do.

Jacob had promised Rachel, and he had to keep his word. Otherwise he would be deceiving Rachel. So that is why Jacob married the two sisters. It is a very simple idea. I am not allowed to deceive. I promised this girl that I would marry her. My stringency cannot go against what I am really obligated to do.

The lesson

The lesson is clear and simple. When we take upon ourselves to be strict with something, it cannot be at the cost of somebody else. You cannot hurt another person because you want to be so religious, so righteous. Wait a second. Do not damage others with your righteousness.

This is exactly what Jacob did. He did not want to deceive Rachel and break his promise to marry her, just because he was being strict. He did not want to avoid marrying two sisters only because the Jewish people in the future would not marry two sisters. That is not proper behavior.

This is a lesson for each one of us. Be careful when you are strict with yourself. Do not do it at the cost of others.

Good Shabbos.

Talk from Rabbi Tuvia Serber


The above is a representation of the spoken text converted to written text.

© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further.

Our blogs may contain text/quotes/references/links that include copyright material of 
Mechon-Mamre.org, Aish.com, Sefaria.org, Chabad.org, and/or AskNoah.org, which we use in accordance with their policies.