…Yet Without J’sus
In Genesis 49, Jacob blesses all his sons before his death. The blessing he gives to Judah is described as follows:
10The scepter shall not depart from Judah, nor the student of the law from between his feet, until Shiloh comes, and to him will be a gathering of peoples.
|ילֹֽא־יָס֥וּר שֵׁ֨בֶט֙ מִֽיהוּדָ֔ה וּמְחֹקֵ֖ק מִבֵּ֣ין רַגְלָ֑יו עַ֚ד כִּֽי־יָבֹ֣א שִׁילֹ֔ה וְל֖וֹ יִקְּהַ֥ת עַמִּֽים
Some Christians claim that the last political authority in Judah was King Herod and that, since no one has become king over Israel after him, Jesus must have inherited this kingship. They argue that Jesus, as the (alleged) King of Israel, took over this kingship from Judah for all eternity.
Let’s focus on Herod. He received rulership over Judah from the Romans, but he did not belong to the tribe of Judah. His father, Antipater the Idumaean, was a descendant of Edom, and his mother, Cypros, was a Nabatean Arab princess from Petra. Although Antipater married a Jewish woman, and his family had converted to Judaism in the second century BCE, the right to kingship was supposed to remain within the tribe of Judah. Thus, Herod had no legitimate claim to this kingship, what is an explanation of his paranoid and violent behavior, driven by the fear of losing the throne.
In 2 Samuel 7, it is stated that the kingship of King David is eternal.
16And your house and your kingdom shall be confirmed forever before you; your throne shall be established forever.”
|טזוְנֶאְמַ֨ן בֵּיתְךָ֧ וּמַֽמְלַכְתְּךָ֛ עַד־עוֹלָ֖ם לְפָנֶ֑יךָ כִּֽסְאֲךָ֔ יִהְיֶ֥ה נָכ֖וֹן עַד־עוֹלָֽם:
However, the continuity of this kingship doesn’t mean there were no interruptions until the Messiah, a direct paternal descendant of King David, would assume the throne. For instance, during the Babylonian captivity, there was no king of Israel. King Zedekiah was overthrown by the Babylonians, leading to the destruction of the First Temple. Since then, there has not been a king of Israel directly descended from King David, but the dynasty of his descendants continues.
Similarly, before King Herod, there was no king over Israel from the tribe of Judah. Herod essentially took over the Hasmonean kingship that had originated in the 2nd century BCE when Jewish rebels, the Maccabees, defeated the Seleucid King Antiochus IV Epiphanes. Simon Maccabaeus, from the tribe of Levi1, became the king of Judea in 142 BCE, and eventually, the Romans appointed Herod as king. If the missionaries’ logic were correct, we would be compelled to say that the Messiah must have come before Jesus, as the kingship of Judah had been temporarily abolished over a century earlier during the time of the Maccabees and the Chanukah miracle.2
It’s essential to note that, according to the genealogies of Matthew and Luke, even Jesus did not have a legitimate claim to the throne of King David. This is due to two practical reasons. Firstly, according to the Church, Jesus had no earthly father, meaning he couldn’t be from the tribe of Judah and, consequently, had no right to the throne of David. In Judaism, tribal identity is transmitted through the father, not the mother. Secondly, even if we consider the genealogy of Mary, it does not lead back to King David through Solomon, as 1 Chronicles 22 teaches, but rather through Nathan. However, the Hebrew Bible asserts that the line goes through Solomon.
9Behold a son will be born to you; he will be a man of peace, and I shall give him peace from all his enemies around about, for Solomon will be his name, and I shall give peace and quiet to Israel in his days.
|טהִנֵּה־בֵ֞ן נוֹלָ֣ד לָ֗ךְ ה֚וּא יִֽהְיֶה֙ אִ֣ישׁ מְנוּחָ֔ה וַֽהֲנִיח֥וֹתִי ל֛וֹ מִכָּל־אֽוֹיְבָ֖יו מִסָּבִ֑יב כִּ֚י שְׁלֹמֹה֙ יִֽהְיֶ֣ה שְׁמ֔וֹ וְשָׁל֥וֹם וָשֶׁ֛קֶט אֶתֵּ֥ן עַל־יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל בְּיָמָֽיו:
|10He shall build a House in My Name, and he shall be to Me as a son, and I to him as a Father, and I shall prepare the throne of his kingdom forever.’
|יהֽוּא־יִבְנֶ֥ה בַ֙יִת֙ לִשְׁמִ֔י וְהוּא֙ יִֽהְיֶה־לִּ֣י לְבֵ֔ן וַֽאֲנִי־ל֖וֹ לְאָ֑ב וַֽהֲכִ֨ינוֹתִ֜י כִּסֵּ֧א מַלְכוּת֛וֹ עַל־יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל עַד־עוֹלָֽם:
the argument that Jesus inherited the kingship from Judah faces historical and genealogical challenges, emphasizing the importance of understanding the context and biblical narrative.
By Angelique Sijbolts
 In 1 Maccabees 2:1, it is mentioned that Mattathias, the father of Judah the Maccabee, was a “priest of the family of Joarib.” According to 1 Chronicles, Jehoiarib is listed as a descendant of Aaron (9:10; 24:7).
 The Jewish Response to Missionaries by Rabbi Bentzion Kravitz
 Let’s Get Biblical Volum 2 p. 244. See Isaiah 11:1, Jeremiah 23:5-6 and 33:14 which show that Messiah is a descendant of King David.
See also our blog-serie REDEMPTION