Skip to content

Sukkat Shalom B'nei Noach

Home » Chanukkah is not Found in Tenach or Mishnah?

Chanukkah is not Found in Tenach or Mishnah?

Chanukah and Tenach

Chanukkah, unlike, say, Purim – which even has its own scroll Ester – is not specifically and openly mentioned in the Tanakh. However, this is also impossible because the story happened after the Torah was written. Moses finished writing the Torah in the year 2488 after creation (1273 BCE). The Chanukkah miracles occurred over a thousand years later, in the years 3621-3622 (140-139 BCE). However, since Hashem is beyond time, you can see an indirect and hidden link in the Torah to Chanukkah. The 25 word in Tenach is namely light, is referred to the 25 Kislev, where Chanukkah starts.

Chanukkah and Mishnah

Although the Chanukkah menorah does merit a few scattered mentions in the Mishnah, Rabbi Judah the Prince, the compiler of the Mishnah, did not dedicate a portion of his work to this holiday, this unlike other holidays that have their own tractate. Think, for example, of Sukkot, Rosh Hashanah or Shevuot.

The purpose of the Mishnah was to put the Oral Torah in writing so that this oral tradition would not be lost. Matters that were as widely known as saying the Shema, for example, received little attention in the Mishnah. From the Shema is not even said that it has to be said, but only hints are given about the right time. And so it was with Chanukah. It was so fresh in everyone’s mind that there was no need to write it down. Only much later, they would be added to tractate Shabbat.

But there is another reason it is not mentioned in the Mishnah. The Mishnah, as mentioned above, is the writing down of the Oral Torah. It is addressed to the Jewish people, it is internal literature, it is private, it is a direct connection to HaShem. It is the light of Torah which you have in your heart.

The Chanukkah Menorah, on the other hand, is placed in front of the window

so that everyone can see it. It is meant for the outside world, it is an external sign, even for those who do not (not yet or especially for them ) have a relationship with HaShem.

Thus, the Mitzvah of Chanukkah could not be mentioned in the Mishna as it would contradict the essential nature of the Mishnah because the essential nature of Chanukkah is to spread the light of victory, over wickedness and idolatry and the worship of Hashem, throughout the world.

By Angelique Sijbolts

Sources:Chabad Article: Is chanukah Mentioned in the Torah?, CHabad Article: What Happened to Tractate Chanukah?

© Copyright, all rights reserved. If you enjoyed this article, we encourage you to distribute it further.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.